Showing posts with label global warming. Show all posts
Showing posts with label global warming. Show all posts

Friday, May 15, 2009

The China Problem

In contrast to Sal's approach, I'd like to look at the 'man/nature' question at the collective level - through a particular case of increasing controversy. Krugman's Op-Ed piece today discusses an growing source of worry for climate scientists: China's exponentially expanding environment endangering emissions (how's that for some alliteration?).


China's cumulative carbon consumption - chiefly (cheap) coal - has doubled in a decade and shows no signs of slowing down. Just this January, the government announced its plans to increase coal production by 30 percent over the next 6 years. And they already lead the world in CO2. However, when confronted with critisms of its policies, largely from American and European environmentalist groups, China simply shrugs and says, "Really? Look who's talking."

The majority of global warming can still be attributed to Western nations - who themselves never had to deal with any type of environmental restrictions while going through their own phases of industrial development. And in the U.S., for all the administration's talk about renewable energy and taking the lead on proactively confronting climate change (through such Congressionally unpopular measures as cap-and-trade) Americans still have the highest global levels of per-capita emissions. This is, of course, the very same United States that distinguished itself as almost the only country in the world to thumb its nose at the Kyoto Protocol.

But is Western hypocrisy at all relevant to the issue at hand? Can the world sustain China's development in this manner without suffering severe environmental repercussions? And India's? And Brazil's? If the answer is no, then how do industrialized nations incentivize eco-friendly economic development? Do they even have the ability to do so when countries like the United States have yet to even implement such policies themselves?

Is it even possible to cooperate on this issue or must some short-term/long-term interest threshold first be met? And will we hit such a threshold before we lose the ability to effectively reverse the environmental consequences?