Ian, I had to respond in a full post of my own; I had too much to say that it just wouldn't fit as a comment!
First off, I don’t think it’s fair of you to characterize torture as a possible Conservative value. Besides the fact that it’s contradictory to even call torture a “value” in the first place, self-styled “Conservatives” like Dick Cheney are extremists and more accurately represent a fringe group in America that, I believe, is represented far more in the media than they are in the mainstream population.
You bring up several questions, which, in turn, bring up even more questions; here's where I stand...
1. Whether torture is ever OK:
It’s not.
There’s zero question that torture violates basic human rights and it’s absolutely absurd for anyone to even attempt to make the argument that it’s ever okay, in any way, shape or form. I am severely disturbed that this question is even being debated in the media right now. If someone can find justification for torture, then what can't they find justification for?
The question this raises for me is: what does it say about our society that this argument is being given any kind of credibility at all? And why is it largely coming from members of a party that not only identifies itself as a protector of "traditional American values" but also finds its staunchest support among a demographic that votes according to religious conviction?
Regardless of the reasons cited by those arguing in torture's defense, whether it be due to a misplaced hatred or even a lock-step deference to authority, their stance violates one of the most basic codes of human morality.
Even Fox News Anchor Shephard Smith gets it:
2. Whether its use on suspected terrorists keeps any more safe:
It doesn’t.
As is explained in the video you provided, there is not a single shred of evidence to even suggest torture is an effective tool; experts in the field roundly reject its viability as a method of obtaining information.
Not only is it highly unreliable, but torture-free interrogation techniques exist that are vastly more sophisticated and provide much more accurate results. But don't take my word for it, here's the former CIA Chief of European Operations:
…And that’s before even taking into consideration how engaging in the practice utterly compromises any kind of moral authority whatsoever you may have had, which hamstrings your ability to cooperate internationally with nations that will want to distance themselves from your actions.
Bottom-line? It’s not even useful.
3. Whether water-boarding is torture:
It is.
This claim is almost as bizarre as the first one. And it’s being echoed on mainstream media outlets as well.
Water-boarding, i.e., the modern day form of Ancient Chinese Water Torture. Christopher Hitchens thought it couldn't be such a big deal - what's some water on your face, I mean c'mon - so he tried it. Guess what? He didn’t last ten seconds. Weeks later, he’s still having nightmares. His column about the experience should be coming out with the next Vanity Fair.
Meanwhile, Sean Hannity has sneered with derision at water-boarding, offering to undergo it for charity.
…here we are almost a week since he made the claim and he still hasn’t went through with it. Why? Because not only is he full of shit, but he knows it.
If water-boarding is not torture, if water-boarding is not a crime, then why did we have Japanese prisoners of war executed for it?
------------------------------
No, the real question here is why are those who perpetrated such a crime against humanity not being investigated? Why are they not being held accountable?
Why, in the name of everything that is fair and just, are those responsible not being prosecuted?
Why, Obama?
It's more than fitting that you posted just before his press conference tonight, in which he was asked no less than 13 times about his stance on this very issue. His response?
“I believe whatever legal rationales were used, it was a mistake.”
A mistake? Not a crime, Mr. President? Just an "Oops. Well, let's move on." Really? Is that how we reclaim our "moral authority"?
And what about the over 100 detainees who died while held in Iraq and Afghanistan, 27 of whom were kicked to death, shot, drowned, or strangled? What about the fact that the U.S. leadership became aware, very early on, that many of the detainees were innocent of any wrongdoing and should be immediately released -- and chose to ignore it because it would have hurt their approval ratings? Where's that story? Where are those memos?
Thomas Friedman made a couple arguments in support of Obama's decision not to go forward today. One, prosecution taken to its full extent would put Bush, Rumsfeld and others on trial and "rip our country apart." Two, "Al Qaeda truly was a unique enemy."
Mr. Friedman, two things. One, if there are really enough torture-supporters in this country to 'rip it apart' then this is a discourse that needs to take place. Right. Now. Two, that's the type of excuse that could be used to justify anything. And that's exactly the kind of thing the law is supposed to protect against.